IRIN
London, 1 October 2014
Last month, a quiet announcement from UK Home Secretary Theresa May dashed the hopes of thousands of asylum seekers in the UK. A court ruling in April had criticized the very low level of support it gives to those seeking asylum and had given her four months to show how she had calculated that it would cover their needs. The Home Office duly did its sums, but announced that the amount to be paid would not increase.
Dave Garratt, the chief executive of Refugee Action, the organization which took the Home Secretary to court, told IRIN that asylum seekers were coming through their doors, telling them that they were really struggling to survive. But the campaigners did at least force the Home Office to give an account of how the asylum seekers’ allowance – currently just over £5 a day for a single adult – was calculated.
“Essentially what they have done,” says Garratt, “is base it on the expenditure of the lowest 10 percent of people in the UK. But we think that is quite flawed, because that is about expenditure, not about need, and many of those people have other help, from family and friends. It doesn’t take account of the special circumstances of asylum seekers who may arrive without clothes or shoes, and have no stored food to fall back on. We still think it is not high enough, but now we have the analysis written down, at least we have something we can debate about, and the formula will have to be re-applied every year so they can show they are doing their job properly.”
TORTURE SURVIVORS SUFFER MOST
In its own report on the way poverty was affecting torture survivors seeking asylum, Freedom from Torture drew on the experiences of its clients and those who work with them to paint a bleak picture of what happens to torture victims who reach the UK and embark on the arduous process of getting refugee status. “I am exhausted,” says one client, “living with this day by day. I am running out of stamina to deal with the pain.” “Our current living conditions keep our torture trauma still alive,” says another. “We can’t move on.”
British immigration law prohibits asylum seekers from working legally, the purported rationale being that allowing applicants to work would blur the line between asylum applicants and economic migrants, and thereby serve as a “pull factor.” Around 11 other EU states do allow asylum seekers to work – if only six months after their arrival – and such policies do not appear to increase the number of asylum applicants. British government policy, critics suggest, is driven more by misperceptions of public opinion on the right to work than by empirical evidence.
RESTRICTED BENEFITS
A single adult asylum seeker’s allowance is currently only just over 50 percent of the benefit known as “income support” – in itself considered the minimum needed to lead an adequate life. In cases where an initial asylum request has been refused and a destitute applicant is waiting for the result of an appeal, or has agreed to return to their country of origin but is unable to do immediately, the allowance, known as Section 4 support, is no longer paid in cash, but loaded onto a “Azure card”. This can only be used at designated shops, for food and a limited range of other items. The recipient has no money for anything else – bus fares, postage, faxing documents or any of the other expenses needed to pursue his claim.
Accommodation provided to asylum seekers is also very basic – often hostel-style or shared accommodation. These shared houses can also be used for people with other social needs – people newly released from jail or struggling with drug or alcohol problems, which makes some torture survivors feel very nervous and unsafe.
Freedom From Torture reports that poverty and anxiety are seriously compromising the ability of their clients to recover from their experiences. The low level of support means that they are not just relatively poor by British standards, but absolutely poor. More than half of the 85 torture survivors who responded to a questionnaire said they were never, or not often, able to buy enough of the right food for a nutritionally balanced diet. Thirty-four said they were never, or not often, able to buy enough food of any kind to satisfy their hunger.
The worst off were the clients with Azure cards, who could only buy at designated shops – mostly mid-priced supermarkets – rather than in the cheaper discount supermarkets or at market stalls. In one of the designated shops the cheapest form of minced meat now costs £3.75 a kilo, a tin of tuna is 95 pence and a 300gram piece of plain cheese £2. Apples are now in season and abundant, but four apples cost a pound. The daily allowance of around £5 does not go far.
T
Another problem is warm clothes. It is hard on this level of income to save enough for new shoes or winter clothing. Charity shops, which sell good quality second hand garments, are useful but of little help to the Azure card holders, who can only use those run by the Salvation Army or the Red Cross – no help if the only charity shop within walking distance belongs to Oxfam. Card holders are also prevented from saving because they are not allowed to accumulate a surplus on the card – anything more than £5 disappears at the end of each week.
COLD, HUNGRY AND ISOLATED
So torture survivors are cold and hungry, and have no money for anything beyond bare necessities. Unable to visit friends, take part in social activities or even get to their church, mosque or temple, they get isolated and depressed and their recovery is set back still further. They are also often stressed by the asylum application process itself, which is extremely complicated. Missed appointments, and anything else seen as lack of cooperation can lead to a stoppage of benefits. Changes in circumstance can lead to gaps and delays in payments. Freedom from Torture recounts cases of torture survivors being left totally destitute, sleeping in the street or on night buses and searching for discarded food to eat.
IRIN
IRIN is the humanitarian news and analysis
service
of the UN
Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian affairs
The opinions expressed
do not necessarily
reflect
those of the United Nations
or its Member States
Dalla Nostra Corrispondente di Moda Luisa Espanet Novembre 2024 In genere succede il contrario, sono…
Dal Nostro Corrispondente di Cose Militari Antonio Mazzeo 20 novembre 2024 Nuovo affare miliardario della…
Speciale per Africa ExPress Costantino Muscau 19 novembre 2024 "Un diplomatico francese sta rubando i…
Speciale Per Africa ExPress Eugenia Montse* 18 novembre 2024 Cosa sapeva degli attacchi del 7…
Speciale per Africa ExPress Cornelia I. Toelgyes 18 novembre 2024 Un tribunale di Pretoria ha…
Speciale per Africa ExPress Sandro Pintus 17 novembre 2024 Continua in Mozambico il braccio di…